ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_MANIFEST.md
Status: MANIFEST v1.2 — 2026-08-15 — inventory and identity record; authorizes nothing.
Scope: Every file in the adversarial-review corpus classified in ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_CLASSIFICATION.md (v1.5.1), plus the classification round's own deliverables. This manifest records what each file is — identity, instrument, subject, version role, and content digest. Analysis and rationale live in the classification report; this file is the lookup, not the argument.
Versioning rule: This manifest follows the canonical-plus-instance model. ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_MANIFEST.md is the canonical rendering; each cut pins an immutable instance ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_MANIFEST_v<N>.md before the canonical advances. The integrity check is: canonical digest equals newest instance digest.
Digest law: Every file row carries a SHA-256 digest. The digest identifies; the filename locates. If a filename and digest disagree with this manifest, the digest governs — a matching digest under a different name is the same artifact; a matching name with a different digest is a different (or tampered) artifact. Tables show the first 12 hex characters; §5 is the full-digest register.
1. Classification-round deliverables
| File | Digest (12) | What it is | Version role |
|---|---|---|---|
ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_CLASSIFICATION.md |
f51d8af1a1d1 |
Classification report: per-artifact subject + instrument attribution, per-set review counts, attribution-method findings, change log v1.0–v1.5.1 | Canonical. Advances with future cuts; must always match the newest pinned instance |
ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_CLASSIFICATION_v1.5.1.md |
f51d8af1a1d1 |
Byte-identical pin of the canonical at v1.5.1. First retained instance; cuts v1.0–v1.5 were edited in place and survive only as change-log entries | Immutable instance. Never edited |
COPILOT_REVIEW_TRANSCRIPT_2026-08-13_14.md |
88c3a4a59440 |
Verbatim Copilot session transcript (2026-08-13/14), recovered via operator paste; provenance header records reliability flags and operator exclusion from absorption | Corpus artifact #21, single-cut v1.0; stored with deliverables because it was created (preserved) during this round |
DIGEST_ANCHOR_VERIFICATION.md |
72bf04ccdd05 |
Integrity pattern: the digest/anchor law, procedures V-1…V-5, five-failure evidence base, lint hooks, signing successor. Archivist-authored v0.1; a proposal until independently graded per ACP | Canonical, pattern atom |
DIGEST_ANCHOR_VERIFICATION_v0.1.md |
72bf04ccdd05 |
Byte-identical pin of the pattern at v0.1 | Immutable instance |
Integrity check at manifest time: canonical digest f51d8af1… = instance digest f51d8af1… — PASS.
2. Corpus artifacts — Set A: Republic whitepaper, paper-only
| File | Digest (12) | Instrument | Subject | Disposition / flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
republic_critical_analysis.pdf |
27737ec52ea5 |
Gemini (F3) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc7 | Consumed. Retains [cite: 1] markers (F3 vendor tell) |
REPUBLIC_v1_0-rc7_critical_review.md |
83bbcc3da2b3 |
OpenAI (F1) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc7 | Consumed |
Republic_Whitepaper_Critical_Analysis.docx |
8eed26239c2e |
Grok (F2) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc7 | Consumed |
adversarial_review_republic.pdf |
85d55e4b84b3 |
Gemini (F3) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc8 | Consumed. Includes citation-verification table refs [1]–[16] |
REPUBLIC_v1_0-rc8_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW.md |
4d1776169642 |
OpenAI (F1) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc8 | Consumed. Operator-anchored (v1.5.1); grades rc8 against its own rc7 findings; probes A–G; late enrollment v1.5 |
Republic_Whitepaper_rc8_Adversarial_Review.docx |
c538ecf1d4b6 |
Grok (F2) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc8 | Consumed |
COPILOT_REVIEW_TRANSCRIPT… (pass 1) |
88c3a4a59440 |
Copilot (F6) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc4 | Excluded from absorption; preserved for provenance. rc4 read after two failed rc7 uploads |
Set B: Republic repository-grounded
| File | Digest (12) | Instrument | Subject | Disposition / flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
repository_audit_republic.pdf |
302a01c28cef |
Gemini (F3) | tecthulhu/republic at HEAD vs whitepaper v1.0-rc9 |
Consumed. Operator anchor for F3 |
REPUBLIC_RC9_REPOSITORY_GROUNDED_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW.docx |
717eb959ea3b |
OpenAI (F4) | Whitepaper v1.0-rc9 + public repo (inspected 2026-08-14) | Consumed. Operator anchor for F4; [W-n]/[R-n] citation discipline |
Republic_Repo_Informed_Feedback.docx |
4b5cf2c4e328 |
Grok (F2) | Whitepaper through v1.0.1 + public repo | Consumed. Operator anchor for F2; updates its own prior rc-line reviews |
Set C: Companion subset (ACP + VSB)
| File | Digest (12) | Instrument | Subject | Disposition / flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Review_ADV_COMP_VAL_SCOPE_BINDING.md |
d847e1729f50 |
DeepSeek (F5) | ACP v0.2 + VSB v0.1 | Consumed. False self-label: frontmatter claims "Grader: Claude … different-session"; all ACP §8 provenance tags wrong as written; true independence class cross-model. Operator-anchored via exact-match re-supply. File retains the false frontmatter internally — this manifest row and the classification report are the corrections of record |
VALUATION_ACP_COMPANION_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW.md |
fee506c693a8 |
OpenAI (F1) | ACP v0.2 + VSB v0.1 | Consumed |
Companion_Subset_Adversarial_Review.docx |
1d0569e1bf04 |
Grok (F2) | ACP v0.2 + VSB v0.1 | Consumed |
Adversarial_Review_Companion_Subset.pdf |
53f9a08ba035 |
Gemini (F3) | ACP v0.2 + VSB v0.1 | Consumed |
VSB_ACP_ABSORPTION_REVIEW_FINDINGS.md |
013f4aa6b48c |
Claude (CL) | VSB v0.2 + ACP v0.3 (absorption round; F-A1…F-A5) | Consumed. Second-order pass; self-discloses author-adjacent, uncalibrated. Its instrument-class ledger is flagged for re-annotation after the F5 reclassification |
COPILOT_REVIEW_TRANSCRIPT… (pass 2) |
88c3a4a59440 |
Copilot (F6) | Mixed: whitepaper excerpt + ACP v0.2 + VSB v0.1 | Excluded from absorption; preserved. Fabricated grader roster (lists operator as human grader), false cross-substrate claim, self-declared "binding" verdict |
Set D: Magistracy / emergence
| File | Digest (12) | Instrument | Subject | Disposition / flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
MAGISTRACY_REVIEW_FINDINGS.md |
77dcc408c5ce |
Claude (CL) | MAGISTRACY_PATTERN v0.3 + emergence analysis v0.1 (F1–F12) | Consumed |
MAGISTRACY_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_COMPREHENSIVE.md |
ad6adb9a649f |
OpenAI (F1) | MAGISTRACY_PATTERN v0.4 + emergence v0.1/v0.2 + ACP + VERSIONS manifest | Consumed. Also a second-pass external input to Set C; counted once here |
Set E: Resolvable/Resolved-Reference Register (RRR)
| File | Digest (12) | Instrument | Subject | Disposition / flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
RRR_v0_1_INDEPENDENT_GRADE.md |
2cc0c041d2cd |
Claude (CL, I-C2) | RRR v0.1 (findings RRR-1…10) | Consumed |
RRR_COVER_NOTE.md |
11fc55e922dd |
Claude (CL, I-C2) | Transmittal of the I-C2 grade | Meta-artifact (not a review pass) |
RESOLVED_REFERENCE_REGISTER_v0_1_adversarial_review.md |
3fe96d873f81 |
OpenAI (F1 = I-X1) | RRR v0.1 (15 sections) | Consumed. Source of the DV-1 overturn of the fourth-plane claim |
Resolved_Reference_Register_Adversarial_Review.docx |
de03c079a50b |
Grok (F2 = I-X2) | RRR v0.1 (9 sections) | Consumed |
RRR_MULTI_INSTRUMENT_SUMMATION.md |
30a41327eb24 |
Claude (CL, I-C3) | Full RRR review stack (ledger + findings RRR-11…17) | Consumed as one pass + ledger meta-function; self-discloses compiler correlation |
3. Roll-up
22 corpus artifacts (21 files in the upload set + the preserved Copilot transcript) · 22 evidenced review passes — 20 consumed, 2 preserved-but-excluded (both Copilot) · 6 instruments, every fingerprint family operator-anchored: F1/OpenAI (rc8 review), F2/Grok (repo-informed feedback), F3/Gemini (repo audit), F4/OpenAI (RC9 review), F5/DeepSeek (re-supply match), F6/Copilot (paste), CL/Claude (self-declared + corpus-internal corroboration).
Standing corrections this manifest carries: (1) Review_ADV_COMP_VAL_SCOPE_BINDING.md is DeepSeek regardless of its internal Claude frontmatter — the digest d847e1729f50… binds that correction to the exact bytes; if a wrapped copy with a corrected header is ever cut, it enrolls as a new digest with lineage to this one. (2) The two Copilot passes are excluded from all consumption counts. (3) The absorption round's instrument-class ledger predates the F5 reclassification and awaits re-annotation.
3a. Source-session register (operator-supplied 2026-08-15)
The originating chat sessions for each external instrument, recorded at the vendor level. Per the digest/anchor law these URLs locate — they are account-gated and resolvable only by the operator, so they strengthen each anchor's recoverability (the origin context can be re-opened, re-exported, or re-verified by the accountable party) without changing its attestational class. Per-artifact session mapping is not asserted: each link is the vendor's review session; individual artifacts attribute to vendors via the anchors in §2.
| Instrument | Source session |
|---|---|
| OpenAI (F1, F4) | https://chatgpt.com/c/6a7dc839-9994-83ea-a212-ed6b6849432f |
| Gemini (F3) | https://gemini.google.com/app/e6914d4eda65ddbb |
| Grok (F2) | https://grok.com/c/dc513d14-96bc-4ccd-84fd-c88a3ce81f7f?rid=f06889b6-5636-483b-8409-485922c2ed81 |
| Copilot (F6) | https://copilot.microsoft.com/chats/utLEwUq4vrNh5r2b7k9GY — origin of the preserved transcript (artifact #21) |
| DeepSeek (F5) | https://chat.deepseek.com/a/chat/s/0455e437-8e06-4514-8354-6c821b2bd51d — origin of Review_ADV_COMP_VAL_SCOPE_BINDING.md; names the true source behind that artifact's false Claude self-label |
Claude-family sessions are indexed separately in SESSION_INDEX v0.2 (Architect / Author / Archivist / Researcher UUIDs).
4. Verification procedure
To verify any file against this manifest: compute sha256sum <file> and compare against §5. To verify the classification deliverables' version integrity: the canonical's digest must equal the highest-numbered instance's digest. A canonical that diverges from its newest instance means an unpinned edit occurred — pin or revert before consuming.
5. Full-digest register
53f9a08ba0351bd4529c218dc8ea4357781b1b6870f0c7e7101c8e440f6acb31 Adversarial_Review_Companion_Subset.pdf
1d0569e1bf04b68c61d728a011c6b17d4933d3da75563b592e45d5fab574a549 Companion_Subset_Adversarial_Review.docx
ad6adb9a649fbe932514327dc81f6f81e348c870997b53691bd39eee76530430 MAGISTRACY_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_COMPREHENSIVE.md
77dcc408c5cefd2bb9598d8f05d02a2899a79b6ef57ed8760f9b9e1c1b8cd9e0 MAGISTRACY_REVIEW_FINDINGS.md
717eb959ea3be8e59f262512a13ff2f5a03c07864d0f6c2e5dd97ad362d51907 REPUBLIC_RC9_REPOSITORY_GROUNDED_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW.docx
83bbcc3da2b375beceb51108a70120c787f79c1d617f8fea445ac1dd01877852 REPUBLIC_v1_0-rc7_critical_review.md
4d177616964217a08d6eff2c1c22b5cf85a12c16ee5a7b5de994e4d854b042cc REPUBLIC_v1_0-rc8_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW.md
3fe96d873f81beafed8c85acbd76995c1936bee1da6faf220cac248dda2af99c RESOLVED_REFERENCE_REGISTER_v0_1_adversarial_review.md
11fc55e922ddd045646cc28d7ecaceed80419ec2ccd5037b67531ed358c9d07c RRR_COVER_NOTE.md
30a41327eb24b1ffdb25fcad934e0f1d80de7c0445bec5e64d910bc655caa7cd RRR_MULTI_INSTRUMENT_SUMMATION.md
2cc0c041d2cd40bd1cdbdf604301bcc6498f3fd246bf417da0edbf4b9e514764 RRR_v0_1_INDEPENDENT_GRADE.md
4b5cf2c4e3280875da24e42d90f09f1f1a09e81890d36c1d1b079975ce9a20f2 Republic_Repo_Informed_Feedback.docx
8eed26239c2e851eab937851c7dc7ae5360c8ff66666fb828224f7dca20e43c1 Republic_Whitepaper_Critical_Analysis.docx
c538ecf1d4b6eedb4b74807280394250502a5fcb1ec6bf95fc1c8e60a9c15d22 Republic_Whitepaper_rc8_Adversarial_Review.docx
de03c079a50bbb956137abd37fceea4e745593447a7d84ed37d897d6cfb519c3 Resolved_Reference_Register_Adversarial_Review.docx
d847e1729f509c33f635085412ee5ba0165957ea71e98414866cd143ef47321d Review_ADV_COMP_VAL_SCOPE_BINDING.md
fee506c693a8fe9faae005db02d8ff7891876681a9371abcad7c5323e8d76a7a VALUATION_ACP_COMPANION_ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW.md
013f4aa6b48ca12afbc47e662bba40a11af9a6a477aac63c2407dc6cff8ecedf VSB_ACP_ABSORPTION_REVIEW_FINDINGS.md
85d55e4b84b31738f5eb4edfbe5dd28d5098c3e1ae38b0df0cd61421817543e2 adversarial_review_republic.pdf
302a01c28cefcaf013bf5dc45a627d2485a93ff4971c509600a0e30584565480 repository_audit_republic.pdf
27737ec52ea562b8ffbd6bca484b87d22ae60b8b76b32fd148289ae9ed31f1ad republic_critical_analysis.pdf
88c3a4a594403ef6d5d0fb111004fbcbf9619e0f2698eb453ffc239f566e118e COPILOT_REVIEW_TRANSCRIPT_2026-08-13_14.md
f51d8af1a1d1b681888478642a4e6180c9071b8a4c855d6ddb9e95b608d70a54 ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_CLASSIFICATION.md
f51d8af1a1d1b681888478642a4e6180c9071b8a4c855d6ddb9e95b608d70a54 ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_CORPUS_CLASSIFICATION_v1.5.1.md
72bf04ccdd051b171cc6915acded18d8ef7434fba21f82debb3a04e9ba80f1df DIGEST_ANCHOR_VERIFICATION.md
72bf04ccdd051b171cc6915acded18d8ef7434fba21f82debb3a04e9ba80f1df DIGEST_ANCHOR_VERIFICATION_v0.1.md
Change log
- 2026-08-15 v1.2 — source-session register added (§3a): operator-supplied origin links for all five external instruments, recorded as vendor-level anchor-recoverability data. DeepSeek and Copilot origins now bind their respective correction records to named sessions. Instance
_v1.2pinned at cut. - 2026-08-15 v1.1 —
DIGEST_ANCHOR_VERIFICATION.mdv0.1 enrolled (canonical + pinned instance) as the pattern formalizing the integrity law this manifest runs. Instance_v1.1pinned at cut. - 2026-08-15 v1.0 — initial manifest. 22 corpus artifacts + 3 deliverables inventoried with SHA-256 identity; all six instrument families operator-anchored; standing corrections (F5 false self-label, Copilot exclusions, absorption-ledger re-annotation) recorded as manifest-carried facts. Instance
_v1.0pinned at cut.